Greyjoy/Fealty 2nd place tournament 1.0

• Versiones

Are you sure you did not use the MIlk of poppy?? My friends says you did in the forth and fifth match of the swiss round. However, if you insinuate there were a combine to defeat you, you have to prove it. If you can't, the only proof is that you do not have a regular deck soo you are rightly disqualified.

If you do not have Poppy in the decklist and you see it and play it, then it's not your opponent's fault, it's just yours. It's very sad to blame people you don't even know, especially in AGOT where the community is everything except like you depict it.

What is possible a devious machination against you ? How,your 3th opponent, can know you don't play Milk of poppy in your deck ?

@rudegnapposorry I bad explained myself. I was speaking of my third game. It's true, I used Milk of the Poppy on Maester Caleotte, but that just because I didn't remember I don't have it in my deck. (i was excited because it was my first tournament). But really do you think a Maester Caleotte could stop a last challenge with Balon? I don't think a Milk of the Poppy could change the game, specially when it finished 15-0. Anyway I NEVER said that there were a combine. I just said it was "a bit strange". So before speak of combines, proofs and anything else learn to read rightly please.

No, you never said it. you only have implied that there had been, in order not to have to be responsible for such an a cusation.

I was the leader judge of the tournament. There was nothing suspect at all. The Poppy was forgotten during the last turn of swiss, having the same sleeves. No one's fault, and no suspect at all on anybody. The owners of the Poppy was out of the top 4 so he did't noticed the card missing. The player in top4 was at his first tournament, unaware of his decklist (printed by a friend), and he didn't count the cards in his deck before the game because of his unexperience. In the deck check of the final game the decklist and the deck does not correspond. So I committed a match loss. That's all. Fabio

First of all I'm the owner of the milk of poppy that put out v.polya99 from the tournament, so it is correct that I can also spend some words about that story. Second, I would like to tell that I appreciate the good organization of ilnan0, that it was a very good judge and owner of the shop where we played. However, hi v.polya99 from the nice nick I suspect that you aren't Italian, so, you should know that Italian GOT community is very old and it is very different from any other italian gamer comunity that I saw in the past, I like to inform you that it is a very good ambience where the players know each other, where you can feel "relaxed" (take care, a tournament is a tournament :-) ) and we can accept some possible errors from a player …… so, when you saw my milk, you could stop the current game and give it me back, all problems would disappear…. but, you play it, and I don't belive that you can't remember if you place a milk of poppy in your deck, more, you wrote your deck on internet with a bad arrogance to have a second false position in a tournament, and again, you wrote bad words regarding me and my friend here (right now you deleted them, but my friends have a screenshots)…. all people here must know your bad behaviour and I suggest you to write here your apologies to me and to my friend.

Ciurle. I beg you to stop this discussion. Polya is a teen ager at his first tournament. He accepted to cancel the post and I talked with him. I don't think that the community needs an autodafe or a public humiliation. I'm sure you all will understand. Thank you.

No one wants an autodafé or lock Polya in a pillory but "sorry, I was wrong" will be fine and will put all this to an end